Skip to main content

Coastline Pizzeria

Round or square? How to pick your pizza at Coastline


A slice of New York-style pizza with pepperoni, burrata and basil, lifted from the pie

Every pizza on our menu comes in one of two shapes, a 16-inch New York round or a 10-by-14 Detroit-inspired square, and the first question at the counter is usually which one. Here’s how the two eat, which pies come in each shape and how to get the same flavor either way. You’ll find us on Marguerite Parkway at La Paz in Mission Viejo.

The round

A New York round is thin and wide. You pick up a slice, fold it down the middle and eat it over the box. The crust stays light under the toppings and chewier at the edge. The slice at the top of this post is The Bonfire: pepperoni, creamy burrata, fresh basil and a drizzle of hot honey.

Every round is 16 inches. There are twelve named pies, from The Coastline Classic, our cheese pizza at $20, up to The Pacific Coast Pie at $33, plus a Build Your Own from $19 and $3 a topping.

The square

A Detroit-inspired square bakes in a pan. The crust comes out thick and open, closer to focaccia than to a thin slice, and the cheese along the pan edge crisps as it bakes. The square in the photo below is pepperoni, on its way out of the pan: the sauce sits over the cheese and the pepperoni cups and chars on top.

A Detroit-style square slice of pepperoni pizza lifted from the pan with a long cheese pull

Every square is 10 by 14. There are five named squares, from The Gold Coast White at $23 to The Dockside at $28, plus a Build a Square with the same toppings as the rounds.

Which one is more pizza

The round. A 16-inch round is about 200 square inches of pizza and a 10-by-14 square is 140, so the round is about 44 percent bigger by area. The square makes up some of that in height. A piece of square is thicker and more filling than a slice of round, so two people who want leftovers should take the round, and two people who want crust should take the square.

Same flavor, both shapes

Most of what we make comes in both shapes, so you can pick by crust and keep the toppings you wanted.

Pepperoni. The Pepperoni is the round, $22, piled with cupped, crispy pepperoni. Motor City Pepperoni is the square, $25, triple pepperoni with mozzarella and pecorino, finished with basil and hot honey.

Burrata and hot honey. The Bonfire is the round, $29, with pepperoni, creamy burrata, fresh basil and hot honey. The High Tide is the square, $25, and drops the pepperoni: burrata, basil, hot honey and olive oil.

Vodka sauce. The Shoreline Vodka Pie is the round, $28: house vodka sauce, crispy pepperoni, mozzarella, basil and a touch of chili flake. The Sunset Vodka is the square, $26, and new: house-made vodka sauce, hot Italian sausage, red onion, ricotta, basil and hot honey, finished with parmigiano reggiano.

Sausage and Calabrian chilies. Amalfi Inferno is the round, $30: pepperoni, spicy Italian sausage, fire-roasted peppers and Calabrian chilies on house red sauce. The Dockside is the square, $28: pepperoni, Italian sausage, Calabrian chilies, roasted peppers, mozzarella and pecorino.

White, no red sauce. The White Pie is the round, $27, and The Gold Coast White is the square, $23. Our sourdough post describes both.

A few pies come round only. The Coastline Classic, our cheese pizza, is one of them, and so are The Margarito, Tomato Ah-Beetz, The Tidepool, Veggie Verde and Sweet Attack!

How to decide

Want the most pizza? Round. Want crust? Square. Want pepperoni and nothing else? The Pepperoni or Motor City Pepperoni, your call on thickness. Table of four or more? One of each ends the argument, and you’ll know which shape you are by the second slice.

If it’s your first visit, our guide to what to order covers the starters, the drinks and when to come.

Come by

Coastline Pizzeria
25102 Marguerite Pkwy Ste A, Mission Viejo, CA 92692
(949) 755-6215

Open Monday through Thursday 11:30am to 9pm, Friday 11:30am to 10pm, Saturday 11am to 10pm, Sunday 12pm to 8pm.

We're Open

Hours of Operation

Monday-Thursday: 11:30am-9pm
Friday 11:30am-10pm
Saturday: 11am-10pm
Sunday 12pm-8pm

Address

25102 Marguerite Pkwy Ste A, Mission Viejo, CA 92692

Phone Number

(949) 755-6215

Subscribe



    © Copyright Coastline Pizzeria 2026 | All Rights Reserved